Auto merge of #1144 - bitcartel:zc.v0.11.2.z7_tx_malleability_gettxid, r=bitcartel
A fix for transaction malleability This PR fixes transaction malleability by not including the sigscript of transaction inputs and joinsplit sigs when hashing the txid. This PR supercedes PR #1101 which was a minimal solution based on a new serialization flag. This PR introduces GetTxid() to distinguish between getting a transaction id and the double sha256 hash. The key changes are: - Adding GetTxid() method to CTransaction which makes a copy of the transaction, clearing out the sigscript and joinsplitsig fields, before hashing. - Verifying that every call to GetHash() actually wants a txid, and replacing with GetTxid(). - Renaming GetHash() to GetSerializeHash() - Rationale: In future, upstream code we want to merge will use GetHash() but we don't know the intent. We should check to see if the intent is to receive a txid (most likely) in which case we replace with GetTxid(), or if upstream actually wants a double hash of the transaction we can use GetSerializeHash(). - Updated genesis data in chainparams.cpp Note that coinbase transactions are excluded as they need the sigscript hashed to help avoid duplicate txids per BIP34: - This modification is related to a question from @ebfull on PR #1101 - "Can we think of a way this change allows us to construct two transactions with the same txid which can simultaneously appear in the blockchain? My guess is it would be possible to construct a coinbase transaction of such a form... this surely breaks invariants." This PR Passes all tests in test_bitcoin (test data was updated in bloom_tests, miner_tests and script_tests).
This commit is contained in:
@@ -171,7 +171,7 @@ double benchmark_large_tx()
|
||||
auto orig_tx = CTransaction(m_orig_tx);
|
||||
|
||||
CMutableTransaction spending_tx;
|
||||
auto input_hash = orig_tx.GetHash();
|
||||
auto input_hash = orig_tx.GetTxid();
|
||||
// Add NUM_INPUTS inputs
|
||||
for (size_t i = 0; i < NUM_INPUTS; i++) {
|
||||
spending_tx.vin.emplace_back(input_hash, 0);
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user